Do we need to scrap the whole notion of "screen-time"?

Some recent research condemns the category “screen-time” as too broad and ill-defined to be meaningful. The World Health Organisation begs to differ. Its new guidelines, released late last month, recommend strict screen-time limits for children - no matter what they’re viewing or how they’re viewing it in.

Over the next two weeks, we’ll examine the screen-time debate in detail. Today: the case for a more nuanced understanding.


Screen-time ain’t screen-time

According to this view, engaging with a screen can be a positive, negative or neutral experience, depending on the content and the context. Or, to put the same idea more simply, “screen-time ain’t screen-time.”

Playing Fortnite for hours, or wandering through the endless corridors of Instagram, cannot and should not be equated with spending the same amount of time composing original music on Garage Band, say, or creating a personal website. In the same way, the screen-time that consumes an increasing part of the school day is one thing. And zoning out with an endless YouTube loop of unboxing videos is quite another.

We all need a way to unwind - whether with Peppa Pig or Bachelor in Paradise. But that doesn’t make it a high-quality experience.

Quality over quantity

In other words, it’s not a matter of quantity, but of quality. Experts point to several dimensions that we should consider when distinguishing between low-quality and high-quality screen-time. First, is it interactive or passive? Games and sites that encourage users to create rather than simply watch score high on the interactivity dimension.

The educational value of screen-time is another critical dimension - although in practice it’s far from clearcut. Watching anime may seem passive, but if it leads to a lively interest in Japanese language, art and culture - well, not so much.

Finally, there’s the dimension of engagement versus disengagement. Screen-time that’s all about zoning out would rank high on the disengagement scale. That doesn’t make it dangerous. After all, we all need a way to unwind - whether with Peppa Pig or Bachelor in Paradise. But that doesn’t make it a high-quality experience.


No simple yardstick

Even within a particular content category - say, social media or gaming - a simple yardstick approach to screen-time may be of limited use.

A large-scale study published this month in the prestigious journal of the National Academy of Sciences looked at the impact of social media screen-time on British tweens and teens and found that, on the whole, the impact on their wellbeing was “trivial.” Overall, the study found, it accounted for less than 1% of their life satisfaction.

Not so fast!

The research had some serious limitations. For one thing, the sample included an odd age range: 10 to 15 - and responses dated back as far as 2009, when the social media world was ruled by the now-defunct MySpace platform, and well before the advent of Instagram and Snapchat.

More importantly, it relied solely on self-reports by children themselves. In other words, kids told researchers how much time they were spending and how they believed their life satisfaction was being impacted. Researchers took those responses at face value.

We need to retire this notion of screen-time.” 

Nevertheless, co-researcher Andrew Przybylski concluded that the findings constituted robust proof that “we need to retire this notion of screen-time.” He told the BBC “The results are not showing evidence for great concern.”

An experimental psychologist affiliated with the Oxford Internet Institute,  Przbykski and colleague Amy Orben have also disputed the nearly universally held view that screen-time before bedtime has negative effects on teens’ psychological wellbeing. They made the claim on the basis of another self-report study in a paper that received extensive media coverage after it was published last month in Psychological Science.

Alarmist headlines!!!

Family Zone cyber expert and clinical psychologist Jordan Foster of ySafe agrees that the category of screen-time can be overly broad.

“Much of the initial research and commentary about this topic has been alarmist, and stating that 'screen time is bad' is too simple and therefore inaccurate to accept this as a conclusion,” she observes.

“What we can say with confidence is that there are positive and negative elements to screen time, both in how much time kids are having and what they are actually doing on their screens.

“Parents who are actively involved in their kids’ digital lives can make more informed judgements about the impact of screen time on their individual child, and make adjustments as needed.”

Next week, we take a look at the other side of the screen-time debate - exploring the latest World Health Organisation guidelines that maintain that, in fact, screen-time is screen-time.

Every day brings new research and opinion about the impact of tech on our kids. Let Family Zone help to keep you informed, so you can be the best digital parent you can be ... for the best digital kid in the whole world. Yours.




Tell me more!

Topics: Parental Controls, Screen time, Social Media

    Try Family Zone for FREE

    Sign up now to try Family Zone for 1 month, totally free of charge.

    Free Trial
    Subscribe to our newsletter
    Follow us on social media
    Popular posts
    Parental Controls | Mobile Apps | Cyber Safety | teens on social media
    Can we talk? 100 questions your teen might actually answer
    Parental Controls | Cyber Safety | Cyber Experts | parenting | roblox
    Roblox: What parents need to know about this popular gaming platform
    Parental Controls | Screen time | youtube | smartphones | WhatsApp | suicide | self-harm | momo
    MOMO unmasked
    Parental Controls | Cyber Safety | tinder | Cyber Experts | parenting | yellow
    Yellow: The Tinder for Teens
    Parental Controls | Social Media | privacy | decoy app
    Hide It Pro: A decoy app to look out for
    Cyber Bullying | Parental Controls | Screen time | Mobile Apps | Cyber Safety | online predators | tiktok | paedophile | child predator | Likee
    LIKEE: What parents need to know about this risky TikTok wannabe

    Recent posts

    Press the reset button on your kid’s online routine

    COVID blew up our teens’ screen-time. It’s time to get them back on track. In the wake of the COVID pandemic, our children are facing a ...

    Bigger families face super-sized screen-time challenges

    If you have more than one child - and statistics show 86 percent of families do - then managing screen-time can be double trouble. Or ...

    'Bigorexia' a growing risk for today's boys

    We’re starting to understand how social media can damage girls’ self-esteem - but what about our boys? New research finds disturbing ...

    The metaverse: Brave new world - or an upgrade for predators?

    Mixing kids and adult strangers in a self-moderated online environment ... What could possibly go wrong?