Research has uncovered a more effective way of altering screen habits - and it’s all about focusing on everything that ISN'T screen-time.
Because when you get right down to it, the most damaging thing about our kids' love affair with their devices is simply the way it nudges aside the rest of life - aka, all the other fun things they could - and should - be doing.
Getting the balance back is easier when you take a positive approach, new research shows.
It’s the difference between “avoidance” versus “approach” goals, explains education researcher Meghan Owenz of Penn State University.
Avoidance v. approach
Avoidance goals - think diets or quitting smoking - are notoriously tough to achieve. They put us in bad moods and make us stroppy. And that’s because they’re all about deprivation.
Being deprived of something that makes you happy - or seems to - is no fun at all. To achieve an avoidance goal takes tremendous commitment and self-control.
But when it comes to screen-time limits, it’s your commitment and self-control that’s the driving force - not your child’s. And that’s exactly where the difficulty lies, and where the pestering and whining begin.
Research shows that 'approach' goals are associated better moods, greater effectiveness and more persistence.
“Approach” goals, on the other hand, simply redirect attention, in a positive way, toward a desired outcome. An approach goal is not about taking away something undesirable, but about adding or encouraging something more positive.
It's like dieting ...
Research shows that approach goals are associated better moods, greater effectiveness and more persistence.
Studies of weight-control have shown that clearly. Over time, weight loss is actually greater for people who are encouraged to eat more fruits and vegetables than it is for those on fat- and sugar-reduced diets.
“Similarly, parents and caregivers can edge out screen-time by encouraging meaningful activities that have long been shown to promote child development,” explains Professor Owenz.
So what kind of activities are those? Professor Owenz uses the acronym SPOIL to spell it out:
S ocial activities
O utdoor time
I ndependent work
Social activities. Spending time in face-to-face interaction with parents, friends and brothers and sisters gives kids the space they need to develop empathy and cooperation skills.
What’s more, adds Owenz, because social activity is “inversely related to recreational screen-time” - in other words, when one goes up, the other goes down - “emphasising them can decrease screen-time naturally.”
Play. Free play not only keeps them occupied - and will be preferred to screens naturally when on offer - it has been linked to a huge range of skills, from impulse-control to achievement in maths and language. Note that the “free” in “free play” means caregivers step back, and give the child space to find their own fun.
Outdoor activities. Again, the relationship with screen-time is inverse. The more hours kids spend outside, the less time - naturally - they will spend on their devices.
Independent work. You may or may not be surprised to learn that kids’ participation in household chores has nose-dived since the advent of the digital age.
The reasons why are complex. But one thing is crystal clear: kids who do chores have higher self-esteem, achieve more academically and are more self-sufficient than kids who don’t.
Literacy. Literacy is so much more than sitting down to read a book now and then. It involves all forms of reading and writing - including being read to and listening to audiobooks.
Kids who develop literacy skills are invariably better able to understand the perspectives of others. They are also less likely to overdo their recreational screen-time.
Bottom line? Encouraging positive activities like these - and setting pester-proof screen-time limits with age-appropriate parental controls - is the most effective way to bring balance to your family’s digital life.
COVID blew up our teens’ screen-time. It’s time to get them back on track. In the wake of the COVID pandemic, our children are facing a ...
If you have more than one child - and statistics show 86 percent of families do - then managing screen-time can be double trouble. Or ...
Mixing kids and adult strangers in a self-moderated online environment ... What could possibly go wrong?