Is "teen brain" really a thing?

A new book is subtitled “why screens are making your teenager depressed, anxious, and prone to lifelong addictive illnesses - and how to stop it now.”

Wow. Really? 

David Gillespie’s Teen Brain has received plenty of attention in the media - and with claims as big as that, it’s no wonder.

But experts are dubious about many of the book’s sweeping generalisations and reliance on what one academic expert calls “dodgy science.” 

Maybe that’s not surprising. David Gillespie’s online bio describes him as “a recovering corporate lawyer, former co-founder of a successful software company and an investor in several software startups.” So science of any kind does not appear to be his strong suit. 

teen brain

In a recent review in The Conversation, Sarah Loughran, a research fellow at the University of Wollongong with a PhD in cognitive neuroscience, examines the evidence for Gillespie’s headline-grabbing assertions and finds the line between social science and sensationalism can get blurred.

Take Gillespie’s definition of puberty, for example: a period in which all “males turn into large, hairy, smelly beasts with no impulse control and a desire for danger and sex.” 

Amusing? Possibly. Sexist? Probably. Scientific? Um, hardly.

And that would be okay, except that Teen Brain purports to deliver data, not opinion or commentary. And far too many of its claims about screen-time, and its pernicious effects on our kids’ brains, are equally unsubstantiated and over-the-top.

Some key assertions are lacking in evidence entirely, notes Loughran - such as the throwaway line that the stimulation we get from caffeine “is identical” to the “dopamine-stimulating apps installed on your child’s device.” 

giphy devicesIs your child's device "causing" anxiety and depression?

In other cases, the relevant research has been misrepresented or misread. Take the claim that teen anxiety has tripled between 2003 and 2011, for example. 

In fact, the data shows that anxiety diagnoses over that period have remained completely stable. The presentation of anxiety symptoms has multiplied - but that has been attributed to increased awareness by GPs and increased likelihood that teens will seek help. 

Gillespie not only insists that an “epidemic” of teen anxiety and depression is upon us, but that “there’s good evidence that [it] is being home-delivered by the modern equivalent of a textbook - the tablet device.”

But then he goes further. Not only is your child’s iPad is “delivering” mental illness, but excessive screen-time is also directly to blame for higher rates of suicide and self-harm among today’s young people. 

This despite the fact that nearly all experts have cautioned - repeatedly - that such behaviours are complex and multi-causal, and can never be reduced to simple a cause-and-effect relationship with screen-time. 

Observes Loughran, “The real shame overall is that the key message, that we should limit our teens’ screen time, is actually a good one.”

Experts agree: It’s almost certainly the case that excessive use of devices is having an impact on teens’ wellbeing - anxiety and depression included.

But alarmist tracts like Teen Brain will not help us understand that impact or how to help our kids, Loughran concludes. Parents are understandably fearful, and fear tends to draw us to easy answers.

"This kind of communication only serves to perpetuate fear and create anxiety – the exact things that the author claims his book will fix.”



Scary headlines about screen-time won't help your kids develop balanced,  healthy and sustainable online habits. But Family Zone's flexible parental controls can. Start your free trial today.

Tell me more!

Topics: Parental Controls, Screen time, Mobile Apps, Excessive Device Usage, teens on social media, screen hygiene, sleep deprivation, teen brain

Try Family Zone for FREE

Sign up now to try Family Zone for 1 month, totally free of charge.

Free Trial
Subscribe to our newsletter
Follow us on social media
Popular posts
Parental Controls | Cyber Safety | Cyber Experts | parenting | roblox
Roblox: What parents must know about this dangerous game for kids
Parental Controls | Screen time | Mobile Apps | musical.ly | Social Media | tiktok | child development | self-harm | sexualisation
One mum's jaw-dropping journey through TikTok
Parental Controls | Screen time | youtube | smartphones | WhatsApp | suicide | self-harm | momo
MOMO unmasked
Parental Controls | Screen time | musical.ly | online predators | tiktok
It's the world's most popular app. And you've probably never heard of it.
Parental Controls | Pornography | Cyber Safety | Social Media | parenting | digital parenting
Pornstar to parents: shame on you!
Parental Controls | Cyber Safety | Cyber Experts | parenting | vpn
VPN apps: what are they and why are teens now using them?

Recent posts

 
Limit screen-time and limit anxiety: Study

New research shows that teens logging higher-than-average time on social media, TV and computers will show more severe signs of anxiety - ...

 
Is Australia's ratings system really good enough?

If you think the PG rating for movies, games and apps is too broad to be a useful guide, you’re in good company. So do more than 75 percent ...

 
One mum's jaw-dropping journey through TikTok

It’s just kids making music videos, right? Wrong.

 
Are screens teaching our kids that violence is normal?

Violence in Australian schools is erupting at an alarming rate, and educators believe unfiltered online content is driving the trend.